This high bar for "clear and obvious" removes much of the VAR's own subjectivity to advise a review, and is why supporters get so frustrated. It's why this penalty wasn't given, and why other incidents won't get punished at times. When you have such a high bar, the VAR is effectively looking for reasons to support the referee, rather than assessing an incident on its merits. Danny Welbeck appears to be barged over by Lisandro Martinez. The official still retains the right to reject it, but it didn't happen once last season. In the Premier League, the pitchside monitor is essentially there for a referee to confirm an overturn. Rather than having such a high bar, they have instructed the VAR to tell the referee to "have another look" at situations where they may change their mind if they watch it again. In the German Bundesliga, they are going the other way. There wasn't a single VAR overturn across the opening weekend, when the average is usually just under one every three games that probably tells its own story. The Premier League said before the season began that it would continue with its high bar over interventions, doubling down on its policy of last season, and it's situations such as this where it's tested to its limit. But the VAR, John Brooks, decided Tierney had made no "clear and obvious error" not to award a penalty. The referee, Paul Tierney, may not have seen the nature of Martinez's challenge. Martinez had no intention to play the ball, and challenged Welbeck with his upper body, forcing him to the ground. VAR review: It should have been a penalty. VAR decision: No foul, a subjective decision by the referee not to give a penalty. What happened: Brighton & Hove Albion were 2-0 up at Old Trafford when Lisandro Martinez went into the back of Danny Welbeck inside the area and pushed him to the ground. VAR in the Premier League: Ultimate guide Man United 1-2 Brighton VAR's wildest moments: Alisson's two red cards in one game Should have been more proactive with substitutions.Video Assistant Referee (VAR) causes controversy every week in the Premier League, but how are decisions made and are they correct?Īfter each weekend, we take a look at the most high-profile incidents and examine the process both in terms of VAR protocol and the Laws of the Game. Adjusted the team by sending Ronaldo on and playing Eriksen deeper that sparked an improvement. It was a bold call to play Eriksen up top and it backfired. Lifted the players and the crowd and fashioned a chance for Rashford that would have counted had it gone in. Failed to convert two glaring opportunities. 5ĭid not get going from the left wing and guilty of committing unforced errors. Had plenty of the ball in the second-half yet did little of note with it. Like Dalot, failed to sustain his friendly form. Played some elegant passes but his role as the centre forward was a misguided experiment that backfired. Not really aligned with Ten Hag's approach but corner forced the own goal. Missed a gilt-edged chance at 0-0 that was costly as Brighton capitalised up the other end. Positioned deep, he was uncomfortable against Brighton's intense frontline and failed to impose himself. 4Įncapsulated United's midfield malaise in a microcosm when he needed six touches in the final third, overran the ball and was carded. So off the pace the crowd had to advise him and booked. 5įortunate to start ahead of Tyrell Malacia and was out of sync at both ends. Booked and fortunate not to concede a penalty. Read more: Erik ten Hag orders change of pre-match preparationīegan impressively but then displayed careless passing and positioning. Had audible backing from the matchgoers and started well but played Danny Welbeck onside to cross for Gross to make it 1-0. Rallied when United brought Cristiano Ronaldo on and contributed to the goal. Started shakily and failed to maintain his propitious pre-season form. Could have better protected his area when he parried the ball to Pascal Gross, who tapped in to make it 2-0.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |